Checking Engineering Reports Against Their Own Evidence
Errors, inconsistencies, and documentation gaps in 72 engineering and environmental reports. We check whether the documents’ calculations, tables, text, and drawings agree with their stated inputs and methods.
Clear reports support decisions about infrastructure renewal, energy and manufacturing expansion, supply-chain resilience, affordable multifamily housing, and climate-risk mitigation. Slowdata aims to keep those reports internally consistent so engineers and inspectors can focus on the underlying measurements, assumptions, and decisions. We conducted a descriptive review of 72 report packages from 71 firms using Slowdata. The review checked calculations, internal consistency, and documented support against the report materials themselves. It did not independently validate the underlying measurements, assumptions, engineering models, or design. The review recorded 967 non-informational findings, averaging 0.17 high-, 8.22 medium-, and 5.04 low-severity findings per report. The leading issue categories were cross-references and comparisons, methods and model basis, and internal consistency, together accounting for 448 findings (46.3% of the total). These findings suggest that auditing systems such as Slowdata could help keep reports aligned as inputs and revisions change, reducing preventable inconsistencies so engineers and inspectors can focus their judgment on the underlying measurements, assumptions, and decisions.
- Engineering consultant reports
- Environmental reports
- Review findings